My Digital footprint entry on Wikipedia – by Tony Fish

tonyfish1.JPG

Yesterday (Jan 6th) I spent several hours updating the Wiki entry for Digital Footprint This has been a learning lesson in wiki editorial as I ended up being blocked (partly my error for removing a delete code when cut and pasting)

I thought (wrongly) that I would update this orphan page on wiki with some content based from my book on digital footprint including links to interesting articles, what people say and views. However as an author it is seen that I have a conflict of interest I cannot add my own material to wiki as I am biased and it is seen as advertising and promotion. However, if I create a dummy account without my name or ask a friend to do add content (same unbiased factual material) it is accepted. It is possible to conclude that an expert in a field is not welcome to add their own comments and content about the field they know about to wiki as there will be a conflict of interest. The same content however can be added by a third party assuming they have the rights to do so. Wiki has spend a lot of time writing guides (they are very good but very long) that justify this position and the guide lines.

Why write this post?

I can write here creating value and reputation for myself and the network by comments. Assumingdigital footprint is about reputation (aka currency of the web) then getting someone else to add yourcontent (to wiki) gives them the reputation and not the creator. Therefore in a wiki world (not an open system one where free to publish as your wish) why be an expert as I would be better off adding others content as my own and gain a better reputation.

Whilst Wikipedia will not change and neither in my view should it change, it means that those who create original thought will get value and reputation from an open system. However it remains the fact the individuals views are biased (blinded) and you cannot trust a single source, mine or Wikipedia.

The person who later changed the edit removed my reference, but left the content. However as the content is published under a creative commons attribution 2 licence, the wiki entry is now in breach as it is quoted without attribution – breaking their own rules.

Conversational, no; thought provoking, yes !

The first carnival of the mobilists of the decade ..

Its nice to see the carnival of the mobilists successfully now under Peggy Anne Salz’s direction. The first carnival is on Ernest Doku’s blog with entries from Chetan, Antoine, Alexei, David and me. I especially like the post of the week which I relate to having an interest in both publishing and comics. :)

Jonathan Ross leaves the BBC – He won’t starve, but he will have to work more

Jonathan Ross leave BBC.JPG

Jonathan Ross – UK’s highest paid TV presenter is to leave the BBC.

Many (including me) think that this is good riddance! since the BBC is taxpayer funded and paying 18 million for a ‘star’ who essentially is an interviewer is an excessive expense of what is taxpayer’s money.

But there is a larger trend here .. It shows the decline of Old media business models like Television.

TV needs mass audiences. Mass audiences need ‘stars’. When audiences fragment, the stars are not really needed. That’s why over the 13 years that Jonathan Ross has been on the BBC, the world around him has changed(for the good in my view)

Ben Preston, Editor Radio times, sums it up nicely when he says

Ross’s decision is a little moment of television history. It’s the moment which proves even the biggest celebrities can’t escape the fallout of the digital explosion.

As audiences fragment across new channels and online, so broadcasters simply can’t afford exclusive deals with the hottest talent any more. He is now be doing what thousands of other forty-something men are already doing in the recession – he’s leaving the embrace of one company where he’s worked for years, and heading off to build a “portfolio career” instead – that’s management speak for going freelance. He won’t starve, but he will have to work more.

It will be interesting to see what Jonathan Ross does in the new media world after having been paid handsomely in the old media world.

Snow in London ..

snow in london.JPG

snow in london 2.jpg

Skype on your TV – very interesting news ..

Link Skype on your TV

Constructivism: Learning via blogging and why you should blog ..

This blog is inspired by a post from Irving Wladawsky-Berger’s blog called Blogging as an exercise for the brain where he shares his view on why blogging is a central part of his life.

He has(like me) also been blogging regularly since May 2005 and says that blogging is like exercise for his brain. It is an excellent post which I recommend you read.

I think blogging (and the Web in general) are the foundation of a new form of learning. I touched on this subject in another recent post Why I pay to support Wikipedia (but I don’t trust it) and so should you

The theory of learning and knowledge acquisition has been of interest to me as I observe my own son and his way of learning. (See Arrowes and why the educational system may need to be revamped. ). Epistemology or theory of knowledge is the branch of philosophy concerned with the nature and scope (limitations) of knowledge. It addresses the questions: What is knowledge?, How is knowledge acquired?, What do people know?, How do we know what we know?. Specific theories of knowledge acquisition include empiricism which emphasises the role of experience, especially experience based on perceptual observations by the five senses; Rationalism which believes that knowledge is primarily acquired by a priori processes or is innate and Constructivism- which we discuss below.

I think that the Constructivist theory of knowledge acquisition will play an important role going forward and (in my view) is the intellectual foundation of ‘learning via blogging’

Constructivism is a view in philosophy according to which all knowledge is “constructed” in as much as it is contingent on convention, human perception, and social experience. Hence, in constructivist theory, knowledge is dynamic, interactive and experience based. This happens through the processes of assimilation and of accommodation. (Adapted from wikipedia)

Assimilation: When faced with new ideas or knowledge, individuals may assimilate that knowledge into their existing framework without changing that framework. This can occur either because the individuals’ experience is aligned with the external representation or if the individual fails to change the internal representation because they mis-interpret the event.

Accommodation: In contrast, when individuals’ experiences contradict their internal representations, they may change their perceptions of the experiences to fit their internal representations. Thus, in the process of accommodation, failure leads to learning.

In constructivism, the learner is a unique, complex and multi-dimensional individual and the learner is encouraged to arrive at his or her own understanding of the truth. The responsibility for learning lies with the learner. The role of the instructor is that of a facilitator.

Learning is an active social process with collaboration among learners.

The constructivism learning process lends itself to blogging. So, this is the reason I blog i.e. I see it as a learning experience .. And it has been a rewarding and a fulfilling experience.

Another way to remind yourselves about the importance of blogging is from the words of Ignacy Paderewski

Practice, practice, practice…

If I don’t practice for one day, I know it;

if I don’t practice for two days,

the critics know it;

if I don’t practice for three days,

the audience knows it.

Source: songstuff

Finally, I was thinking of a picture for this blog and then I thought of the Brick in the wall video .. The anthem of the misfits and almost the exact opposite to the ideas presented here. Enjoy!

Mobile Cloud Computing – Insights from Orange Business services Cloud computing ambitions ..

I have been tracking Mobile Cloud computing – especially from the Operator perspctive. See Mobile Cloud Computing – the silver lining for Operators

Here is the full press release from Orange on Dec 18 Orange Business Services sets out its ambitions in cloud computing

My comments are under AVJ. This shows us where the market is heading. I am not saying about the feasibiluity – but more about the direction. The critical question for me is: How will Operators distinguish themselves from Internet based Cloud providers; What is the fixed – mobile mix; How can they provide end to end security

Orange Business Services sets out its ambitions in cloud computing

Orange announces complete cloud computing services, from infrastructure to real-time business applications;

Leveraging its cloud-ready network, Orange is best placed to provide enterprises with simpler, safer and more flexible cloud services.

Orange Business Services, which has already rolled out successful cloud services, such as IT Plan* and Flexible Computing** , will launch a dozen of new cloud computing services in the coming 24 months, covering six main areas including real-time applications, collaboration, security, infrastructure, cloud-ready networking and vertical solutions for specific industries.

AVJ:

a) IT plan = desktop virtualizatio; Flexible Computing = hosted virtualized infrastructure. I think both have a large FIXED component

b) covering six main areas including real-time applications, collaboration, security, infrastructure,

Cloud computing allows users, whether companies or individuals, to access IT resources and applications from the network relying on its processing and storage capacities.

complete cloud computing services

Complete cloud computing solutions include a full range of services, from infrastructure to real-time business applications, supported by our cloud-ready network ensuring rapid scalability with full security and end-to-end service level agreements.

AVJ:

lots of buzzwords .. but still significant to breakdown to know meaning of:

Cloud ready network, real time business applications, rapid scalibility, FULL security, End to End service level agreement

Our full lifecycle approach allows us to provide our customers with step-by-step guidance during their transition to cloud-based services, accommodating hybrid models, which are the most suitable for many enterprises.

AVJ: Again .. meaning of transition to cloud-based services and hybrid model is unclear

While Internet-class cloud computing brings cost reduction and scalability, it delivers very little visibility on security and can generate performance issues. Within the Orange cloud, we can deliver and manage all business critical applications and IT infrastructure as a service, with a one-stop-shop approach. The complete, end-to-end solutions provide customers with usage-based pricing and self-service through a user-friendly portal.

AVJ: This is an attempt to distinguish itself from the Internet-class cloud computing services. I think Operators will need this to distinguish themselves from the Amazons of the world

the Orange expertise

Orange already has solid expertise with cloud services, in part thanks to a strong existing portfolio and 150 cloud computing specialists. In addition to managing 12,000 servers for enterprise customers, we can design, build and operate private clouds for large multinational companies.

“Operating cloud computing services is in our DNA,” said Barbara Dalibard, president and CEO, Orange Business Services. ” The network is the cloud, and our experience and expertise in network and communications services place us in the best position to deliver high performance cloud computing services to support our customers’ transformation. We are committed to leveraging our global capabilities to deliver secure and flexible cloud computing services to our customers,” Dalibard added.

“Telecom operators are ideally positioned to provide secure and resilient cloud services,” said Camille Mendler, vice president of global service strategies at Yankee Group. “Enterprises need pervasive connectivity to virtualized assets, backed with robust performance guarantees and transparent monitoring tools.”. “Not least, there is an urgent need for trusted intermediaries to federate private, public and hybrid cloud environments. Telecom operators are stepping up to play this critical role.”.

Leveraging our position as “Best Global Operator”***, Orange can rely on its international network, high standard service and security, as well as end-user and device management capabilities, to drive this new generation of cloud services.

AVJ: secure and resilient cloud services,

“Enterprises need pervasive connectivity to virtualized assets, backed with robust performance guarantees and transparent monitoring tools.”. “Not least, there is an urgent need for trusted intermediaries to federate private, public and hybrid cloud environments. Telecom operators are stepping up to play this critical role.”.

I find this statement VERY interesting .. especially the ‘trusted intermediary’ bit

helping customers transform their businesses

Enterprises are seeking ways to transform their businesses, yet most cannot implement change faster than their IT can support. The need for change is the driving force behind the evolution to cloud computing capabilities.

This new computing model alleviates the need for upfront investments when deploying new applications. In addition, cloud computing services are yet another way to help our customers achieve their green IT objectives.

The Orange Business Services complete cloud computing portfolio also includes consulting services to both help customers understand the potential of cloud computing for their business and to plan their transition.

More information on: http://www.orange-business.com/cloud

AVJ: Green IT! how?

And http://www.orange-business.com/cloud is in French! :( I will try and know more

On one hand, one could say that it is a collection of buzzwords(as much of Cloud is) but I genuinely believe that Operators have a role here so I am going to find a lot more.

Comments welcome

Shall keep you posted

kind rgds

Ajit

About me ..

Ajit Jaokar pic 2009.JPG

I thought of using this blog post as a dynamic bio so I can keep it updated ..

Ajit Jaokar is the founder of the London based publishing and research company futuretext focussed on emerging Web and Mobile technologies.

His current research areas include Mobility/Convergence, Smart grids, LTE, Policy, Open systems, Privacy and Cloud computing.

Ajit’s thinking is widely followed in the industry and on his blog, the OpenGardensBlog, which was recently rated a top 20 wireless blog worldwide

In 2009-2010, Ajit was nominated as part of the Global Agenda Council on the Future of the Internet by the world economic forum. He hopes to use this opportunity to further extend the pragmatic viewpoint of the evolution of Telecoms networks in an open ecosystem.

(Note: The Network of Global Agenda Councils plays a significant role in shaping the global agenda by monitoring global issues and elaborating recommendations to address them. Each Council, comprised of 15-20 Members, serves as an advisory board to the Forum and other interested parties, such as governments and international organizations. The Global Agenda Councils also act as the intellectual drivers of the World Economic Forum’s Global Redesign Initiative, an unprecedented international, multistakeholder and multimedia dialogue that aims to develop a 21st-century vision of global cooperation. Members of the G20, the UN and other International Organizations have pledged their support for this initiative. )

Ajit is best known for his books Open Mobile, Mobile Web 2.0 and Social Media Marketing.

His consulting activities include working with companies to define value propositions across the device, network, Web and Social networking stack spanning both technology and strategy. He has worked with a range of commercial and government organizations globally including The European Union, Telecoms Operators, Device manufacturers, social networking companies and security companies in various strategic and visionary roles

His recent talks and forthcoming talks include: CEBIT 2009;MobileWorld Congress(2007, 2008, 2009); Keynote at O Reilly Web20 expo (April 2007);Keynote at Java One; CTIA; European Parliament – (Electronic Internet Foundation); Stanford University’s Digital visions program;MIT Sloan;Fraunhofer FOKUS ; University of St. Gallen (Switzerland);

Media appearances include BBC – Newsnight – 3phone launch; CNN money; BBC digital planet

Ajit chairs Oxford University’s Next generation mobile applications panel and conducts a course on Web 2.0, Social networking, Mobile Web 2.0 and LTE services at Oxford University.

Ajit lives in London, UK, but has three nationalities (British, Indian and New Zealander) and is proud of all three. He is currently doing a PhD on Privacy and Reputation systems at UCL in London. Ajit is a fan of animation especially Tom and Jerry, Tintin and Asterix and likes the music of ZZ Top and other rock bands

You can contact me at ajit.jaokar at futuretext.com

You can follow me on twitter at @AjitJaokar

To join my mailing list, please send me a brief email at ajit.jaokar at futuretext.com

The lost decade, the best decade and the Internet

The lost decade, the best decade and the Internet.jpg

Businessweek called this (1999 -2009) the lost decade. In contrast, when I was in India in December, the Indian Business today headline proclaimed that this was India’s best decade.

An interesting contrast between the tale of two headlines which points to a rising influence of India and China in comparison to the West. But this decade also saw the rise of the Internet and in that sense, the three factors (The lost decade, the best decade and the Internet) are related

When it comes to the Internet, we are all over exposed but under educated. We all ‘use’ the Internet, but not many people appreciate the philosophy behind the Internet

One simple way to understand the impact of the Internet is to study it in terms of ‘laws’ and Adam Singer does a great job by summarising the Buzzworthy laws of the Internet

To summarise, these are

- Long tail

- Streisand effect

- Metcalfe’s law

- Participation inequality

- Tipping point

- Moore’s law

To this, I can add two more laws:

The Bandwidth law – bandwidth doubles approximately every two years at the top end (also indicated by Jakob Nielsen). And also, the impact of Mobility especially the ability to capture information from mobile devices, impact on emerging markets and the proliferation of the full Internet on Mobile devices through Widgets, HTML5 etc

So, in my view, the relationship between the three factors is:

a) The Internet magnifies the Good, the Bad and the Ugly

b) The Internet provides Information symmetry

As early as 1996, I read an excellent book called The Death of Money written by Joel kurtzman in 1994

Much of what Joel Kurtzman pointed out in 1994, existed for a long time – specifically a change in the economic nature of money in the United States following the decoupling of US Dollar from the gold standard in 1971 (The Gold standard was created by the Bretton Woods system after world war two). This de-coupling happened in Richard Nixon’s time and since then we have been printing money leading Warren Buffet to famously call Derivatives as the weapons of financial mass destruction

But the last decade really brought about the death of money as we know it because the Internet accelerated the financial shortcomings by providing the connectivity and provided the transparency(information symmetry) to create a more balanced global ecosystem

On the way back to the UK, I was reading yet another fascinating book about India and China called Billions of Entrepreneurs: The Yin and Yang of China and India

I highly recommend this book and will do a book review later in the month

I can only see this trend continuing in the next decade as well.

Image: The money changer by Rembrant

Why I pay to support Wikipedia (but I don’t trust it) and so should you …

Jimmy_Appeal_2009.jpg

The apparently contrarian title of this blog is designed to show why you should support Wikipedia because it is a new form of media which makes you think for yourselves and to trust no one but your own judgments ..

I have supported Wikipedia financially every year and I recommend you to do the same…

Much has been said about Wikipedia and how you cannot trust the material on Wikipedia and that it may change (and it does).

Anyone can ‘edit’ it and therefore it cannot be ‘trusted’…

Ironically, as I said in the title of the blog, I do not trust Wikipedia .. And nor should you. .. Instead you should trust youselves and treat Wikipedia as a starting point ..

Think about it…

If you cannot trust a source anyone can edit, then it implies that you should only trust a source that only a few can edit aka newspaper editors and others.

The same people who want you to trust in ‘someone else’ – are the ones who want you to abdicate your thinking to that other entity i.e. Religion, governments, society, your tribe or most importantly… Your newspaper.

Hence, the new forms of media are the ones who will provide you information and analysis from many different sources and leave you to make your own decisions. These media forms (ex Wikipedia and YouTube) are thus the starting point of your ‘fact finding’ about a topic…

They should be viewed as the first point of your investigations and not an end in itself. In contrast, the traditional media wants you to ‘trust’ their own point of view .. And hence to trust an editorial which is created by themselves.

See also Doc Searls perspective on What is right with Wikipedia which also links to wall street journal article about research which criticizes Wikipedia Volunteers Log Off as Wikipedia Ages

Link to donate to Wikipedia

You can post your stories of wikipedia HERE